Join Chalkbeat Tennessee’s free each day e-newsletter to maintain up with statewide schooling coverage and Memphis-Shelby County Faculties.
An effort to oust Memphis-Shelby County Faculties Superintendent Marie Feagins was placed on maintain Tuesday evening when a divided college board voted to push the controversy to subsequent month.
In a 5-4 vote, the board referred a decision to oust Feagins over allegations of “skilled misconduct” to a committee assembly in January.
Feagins forcefully denied the allegations close to the top of a heated board assembly that was repeatedly disrupted, describing what she had heard as “meritless and baseless.”
The decision to terminate Feagins’ contract — introduced by board Chair Joyce Dorse-Coleman — claims she violated the phrases and should be eliminated instantly. The decision alleges that Feagins:
- Misled the board and didn’t current proof of her assertion, made in a piece session, that district workers had been paid $1 million in time beyond regulation for time not labored.
- Accepted a greater than $45,000 donation with out board approval, then misrepresented what occurred in violation of board coverage.
- Was dishonest with the board and public a couple of federal grant and a missed deadline.
Board members dissatisfied with Feagins’ efficiency have aired these considerations beforehand, a transparent sign that the connection between the superintendent and board had eroded. However the effort to oust her Tuesday fell brief after a gathering by which Feagins supporters voiced their anger on the prospect of her being terminated lower than 9 months after she took the job.
When given the microphone, Feagins mentioned she had but to see the decision and heard in regards to the effort to finish her contract from the media after the assembly was introduced Monday.
“I’ve mentioned time and time once more, if I’m ever the barrier I’ll depart,” Feagins mentioned. “What I’ve heard is meritless and baseless. I’ve been clear about it and may refute all the things that’s been acknowledged.”
She added: “My need to be clear has been weaponized in opposition to me.” She additionally referenced working with an lawyer relying on how issues proceeded.
Dorse-Coleman mentioned in introducing the decision: “The board believes that Dr. Feagins has engaged in conduct detrimental to the district and the households it serves.”
Board members Michelle McKissack, Amber Huett-Garcia, and Tamarques Porter spoke out in opposition to the decision and fought efforts to push via a vote on it Tuesday evening.
“Let’s not get distracted. This can be a distraction,” McKissack mentioned.
“That is silly,” Huett-Garcia mentioned. “We’re not good right here, but when we do that tonight, we’re saying to the general public we aren’t prepared to do the arduous work.”
Different board members, nevertheless, had been resolute in wanting to finish Feagins’ tenure. Board member Sable Otey mentioned there have been complaints about how MSCS is run since August.
Board members McKissack, Huett-Garcia, Porter, Dorse-Coleman, and Keith Williams voted to maneuver the dialogue to committee in January.
Dorse-Coleman was the deciding vote and mentioned to reporters after the assembly she needed to “maintain it truthful” by giving the district time to look over the details.
“There’s a disconnect and it’s a really sturdy disconnect that our superintendent has created,” she mentioned.
When requested if any of those considerations had been dropped at Feagins throughout an analysis, Dorse-Coleman mentioned the analysis was not accomplished as a result of “when individuals had been making an attempt to speak to her, they didn’t get an opportunity to.”
Greater than 100 Memphians attended Tuesday’s assembly, a lot of them cheering Feagins as she walked into the auditorium and booing board members.
Dorse-Coleman mentioned on the assembly that 57 individuals had been signed up for the general public remark portion; the board diminished the time restrict from three minutes for every speaker to 1 minute. Almost all public feedback had been in assist of the superintendent. Some audio system requested the board to postpone the vote.
The drama round Feagins comes because the district faces critical educational and monetary challenges — and simply because it was looking for to revive group belief after earlier management turnover and a protracted 18-month course of to discover a alternative.
The board employed Feagins in February and agreed to a four-year contract that paid her $325,000 a 12 months, beginning April 1. If the board fired her with out trigger, she’d be due a severance fee of about $500,000.
Feagins beforehand held a management place on the Detroit Public Faculties Group District. She was chosen from a subject of three finalists to be the primary outdoors chief of Memphis-Shelby County Faculties for the reason that district was created via a merger a decade in the past.
In the course of the interview course of, Feagins defined how she used knowledge to assist get extra Detroit college students on observe to graduate, spoke of empowering academics, and described efforts to extend father or mother engagement by translating schooling jargon into comprehensible phrases.
The board and Feagins clashed early, nevertheless, over her elimination of about 1,100 positions over the summer season, her allegations of time beyond regulation abuse by district workers, her response to highschool air-con issues, and her plans to shut or consolidate faculties beneath a broader services overhaul.
Whereas Feagins gave board members detailed, data-heavy stories throughout their conferences, a number of steered she was not clear or collaborative sufficient in regards to the huge choices and shifts she made.
On the similar time, many group members had been glad to see Feagins taking steps to shake up a district they seen as top-heavy and in want of serious reforms. Audio system on Tuesday evening praised Feagins as a visionary and connector, whereas threatening to recall board members.
Earlier Tuesday, McKissack launched a press release asking her colleagues to delay the vote, citing group assist for Feagins.
“I imagine we must always give Dr. Feagins the chance to handle any considerations immediately and collaboratively,” McKissack mentioned within the assertion. “This second requires endurance and dialogue in the perfect curiosity of our college students and households.”
Dorse-Coleman mentioned after the assembly that group assist for Feagins didn’t affect her tie-breaking vote.
“What I introduced tonight, I nonetheless really feel that approach,” Dorse-Coleman mentioned, referring to the decision. “She has not correctly communicated numerous issues with us.”
The district has been beset by management turmoil going again to a minimum of August 2022, when then-Superintendent Joris Ray resigned amid an investigation into allegations that he abused his energy and violated district insurance policies. The board agreed to pay him a severance of practically $500,000 and ended the investigation.
District administrator Toni Williams took over as interim superintendent, pledged she wouldn’t search the job on a everlasting foundation, modified her thoughts and utilized for the function, then backed out of the method. The district restarted its nationwide search in June 2023, after the board agreed on a contemporary set of job {qualifications} and standards.
The varsity board has a distinct look than it did when Feagins was employed: November’s election resulted in 4 of its 9 members being changed.
The newest turmoil might reignite efforts by state leaders and lawmakers to grab some management of the Memphis district. Earlier this 12 months, a Memphis lawmaker floated a proposal to increase the varsity board with extra members appointed by state officers.
