Join Chalkbeat Tennessee’s free publication to maintain up with statewide training coverage and Memphis-Shelby County Faculties.
A Tennessee lawmaker needs Memphis-Shelby County Faculties to return below the oversight of a state-appointed administration board to deal with considerations in regards to the district’s management, amenities, curriculum, and funds.
Rep. Mark White advised Chalkbeat he intends to introduce laws that may create a seven- to nine-member board, stuffed by Memphis-area residents who’ve experience on these matters, that may oversee the native elected college board till the state deems the district has stabilized.
The Memphis Republican, who additionally chairs the Home Schooling Committee, mentioned he’s engaged on laws modeled after a Texas legislation that allowed that state to take over Houston’s almost 200,000-student public college system, the nation’s eighth largest district, in 2023. The Texas Schooling Company changed Superintendent Millard Home II, a former district administrator in Clarksville, Tennessee, with a brand new chief and an appointed board of managers comprising native residents.
However White mentioned that, below his invoice, the elected board for Memphis-Shelby County Faculties would stay in place, “as a result of they’ve a number of duties to hold out, and there are a thousand shifting elements to operating a faculty system this huge.”
He added, nonetheless, that the board must work below the administration board’s supervision till state officers consider the district has stabilized.
“We’ve obtained to do one thing,” White mentioned, “and we expect this mannequin will work.”
A spokesperson for Memphis-Shelby County Faculties mentioned Friday that the district had no remark about White’s draft laws.
Earlier this week, MSCS board member Michelle McKissack advised Chalkbeat that whereas she doesn’t desire a state takeover, she additionally understands why some neighborhood members could be open to it. McKissack was one of many strongest defenders of former Superintendent Marie Feagins and sought to dam her ouster.
“It’s at all times greatest for a faculty district to be left within the fingers of the people who find themselves domestically within the district, who’re proper there with the parents,” McKissack mentioned. “You at all times wish to have native management whenever you’re speaking about training.”
“However on the similar time,” she mentioned, “our native college board is just not listening to the individuals who elected them. … I see the place it’s coming from to a sure extent.”
Discuss of a state takeover of Memphis-Shelby County Faculties has swirled for weeks, even earlier than the college board fired Feagins on Jan. 21 after a nine-month tenure marked by tense relations with some college board members.
Feagins loved widespread assist from throughout the district and neighborhood for shaking up the paperwork and aggressively shrinking central workplace employees, transferring lots of the employees to understaffed faculties.
The board fired her anyway, regardless of pleas from White, the Shelby County Fee, a few board members, and neighborhood leaders to carry off and attempt to work by means of their variations so as to keep away from one other extended seek for a brand new superintendent.
On Monday, Home Speaker Cameron Sexton advised Memphis radio station KWAM that the state will take over the college system due to the management turnover. He referred to as Feagins a “nice chief” and pledged that the state will set up a distinct board “to get the colleges again below management.”
Lt. Gov. Randy McNally agreed that the established order is unacceptable.
“If the board can not get its act collectively, and it’s changing into very clear they’ll’t, the state must step in,” McNally advised Chalkbeat in a press release.
State oversight or state overreach?
Democratic state lawmakers representing Memphis characterize any change at school board governance as “state overreach,” particularly in a neighborhood the place energy, politics, and race have lengthy loomed massive within the relationship between the state and the general public college district.
Sen. Raumesh Akbari mentioned gutting the authority of a domestically elected board could be an “assault on democracy,” whereas Sen. London Lamar mentioned it might set a troubling precedent. Each referred to as it a step backwards.
“Memphis-Shelby County Faculties are making progress, regardless of being a part of one of the vital underfunded state training programs within the nation,” Akbari mentioned.
Final 12 months, for the third straight 12 months, the district earned the very best potential rating for tutorial development below the state’s accountability system, exceeding state expectations.
State Rep. G.A. Hardaway, who additionally represents Memphis, mentioned the takeover discuss reminds him of when the state took over dozens of Memphis faculties for placement within the state-run Achievement College District starting in 2012. The college turnaround initiative, which is prone to be shuttered by lawmakers this 12 months, has been wildly unpopular and largely unsuccessful in enhancing educational efficiency in low-performing faculties.
“We failed kids miserably with the ASD, and now we have now the nerve to say we’re going to create ASD on steroids by taking a chainsaw to Memphis-Shelby County Faculties? That doesn’t make sense,” Hardaway mentioned.
White, whereas acknowledging the failures of the turnaround district, calls that comparability “apples and oranges.”
“That was extra of an instructional intervention that concerned faculties, lecture rooms, and academics. This might be a administration intervention,” he mentioned.
White mentioned he has met within the final week with Shelby County Mayor Lee Harris, interim Memphis college Superintendent Roderick Richmond, and faculty board member Sable Otey, amongst others, to speak about neighborhood backlash over Feagins’ firing, and what ought to occur subsequent. Earlier this month, the Shelby County Fee handed a decision declaring no confidence within the college board.
White mentioned that in drafting the invoice, he’s conferred with Sexton’s employees and Sen. Brent Taylor, the Memphis Republican who would be the measure’s co-sponsor.
State takeover of Houston district is steeped in controversy
The Texas Schooling Company appointed a nine-member board of managers and put in a brand new superintendent to supervise the Houston district starting in 2023, decreasing the elected board to an advisory physique. The plan is to return the district to native management as soon as the district meets established standards.
The modifications in Houston have been sweeping, and sometimes divisive. In keeping with The Houston Touchdown, the brand new state-appointed management redesigned educating and studying, sought to tie instructor pay extra intently to pupil check scores, boosted some instructor salaries by tens of 1000’s of {dollars}, and slashed spending on many non-classroom bills.
Whereas state check scores improved in 2024, critics of the takeover have pointed to excessive instructor turnover and query the long-term affordability of the turnaround plan, the Touchdown reported.
Others referred to as the takeover the most recent instance of Republican and predominantly white state officers asserting energy in closely minority and Democratic-led cities.
Some Houston officers have referred to as for an finish to the takeover and an investigation into why and the way it occurred.
Tennessee lawmakers can be shifting on to different enterprise now that they’ve accomplished a particular session that was headlined by passage of a common college voucher invoice. White mentioned that his draft laws would seemingly name for the change in Memphis governance to occur July 1, although it might be sooner.
“Some are calling this a takeover,” he mentioned, “however I name it an intervention.”
Marta Aldrich is a senior correspondent and covers the statehouse for Chalkbeat Tennessee. Contact her at maldrich@chalkbeat.org.
Memphis-based reporter Dima Amro contributed to this story.
