Label: Geffen Information | Launched: 8 September 2023 | Producer: Dan Nigro
GUTS is Olivia Rodrigo’s second album, a guitar-heavy pop-punk and alt-rock document in regards to the psychological value of early fame, the compulsive stupidity of wanting the flawed particular person anyway, and the strain of being boxed in at 20 years outdated.
It’s louder, sharper, and extra structurally formidable, and extra prepared to let these constructions break than SOUR. Additionally it is funnier, which no person who approached it as a teen breakup document sequel anticipated.
The album works when Rodrigo trusts the specificity of the state of affairs she is definitely in. It falters when she retreats to broader emotional territory and the manufacturing smooths over the place stronger pondering ought to be. That cut up runs roughly alongside the monitor order.
What GUTS Is Truly Doing
Rodrigo informed interviewers that the album is about rising pains and making an attempt to determine who she is at this level in her life. That’s much less dramatic than the framing most critics utilized to it, and nearer to the reality.
The album isn’t a reinvention. It’s Rodrigo and producer Dan Nigro asking how far they’ll push the sounds they established on SOUR earlier than these sounds cease working, whereas writing a couple of state of affairs SOUR didn’t cowl: the disorientation that arrives after getting the factor you wished.
The title carries three readings concurrently. She is spilling her guts. She has been hit within the intestine. It takes guts to say what she says. The place SOUR described the aftertaste of one thing gone flawed, GUTS describes the second earlier than you know the way badly it’ll damage.
Nigro handles every part from acoustic guitar to drum programming throughout the document. A part of the album was made at Electrical Woman Studios in New York, and you’ll hear a room consciousness within the manufacturing. Depend-ins are left in. Audible discussions between musicians earlier than sure takes.
It marks a deliberate break from the scientific polish that makes most information at this business stage indistinguishable from one another.
The choice to let the seams present can be a press release about what sort of document Rodrigo needs this to be: one thing that seems like individuals in an area making a specific noise, not a product with smoothed edges.
Observe by Observe
all-american bitch
The title comes immediately from Joan Didion’s The White Album, the place Didion encounters a hippie who refers to his mom as an all-American bitch. Rodrigo stated in an Interview Journal dialog with Phoebe Bridgers that she liked the phrase due to its embedded contradictions.
The track is in regards to the particular absurdity of being anticipated to carry out gratitude, composure, and modesty concurrently, whereas internally coping with every part these performances are designed to suppress.
The construction is constructed round a deliberate mismatch. Delicate acoustic verses, one thing near late-90s folk-pop, then a distorted refrain that hits arduous sufficient to genuinely startle on first hear.
Rodrigo’s vocal follows the identical cut up, and it does extra work than most criticism has acknowledged. Within the verses she is exact and nearly placid, the voice of a lady who is aware of what’s required of her and has delivered it sufficient instances to do it effectively.
The refrain abandons that solely. The transition isn’t a launch of emotion within the generic sense. It’s the failure of the efficiency. You hear the efficiency fail in actual time.
unhealthy thought proper?
The album’s most underexamined monitor. Rodrigo narrates an evening spent at an ex’s condominium in actual time, with the sort of self-awareness that’s a lot more durable to jot down than it sounds.
The humour works as a result of it by no means diverges into self-pity or lets the ex disappear into abstraction. He’s current all through, a particular mediocre particular person she has already assessed clearly and is selecting to return to anyway.
The joke is that each issues might be true: full information of the state of affairs, and the choice to disregard it. Writing that place actually is more durable than the usual breakup track, and he or she doesn’t soften it.
Learn our full breakdown of “unhealthy thought proper?” lyrics which means
Vocally she makes use of a half-deadpan register right here that doesn’t seem elsewhere on the album. The supply is conversational with out being flat, and it offers the spoken verses a dryness that lands with extra pressure than a sung efficiency would.
The guitar work on the finish of the monitor, devices panning because the construction loosens, is a manufacturing alternative that rewards headphones. Nigro lets chaos in, controls it simply sufficient, then steps again. That could be a ability that will get undervalued in pop manufacturing.
A element price noting: “all-american bitch” ends with a faint knock on a door. “unhealthy thought proper?” opens with a document scratch and Rodrigo whispering “hey,” as if whoever knocked was now being answered. Sequencing like that’s not unintentional.
Vampire
The lead single introduced the album and divided individuals earlier than that they had heard the remaining.
The structural comparability to “drivers license” is honest: sluggish construct on the piano, escalating vocal depth, cathartic rock end. What “vampire” does otherwise is within the lyrical precision and in what the manufacturing builds towards.
The topic is a manipulative older determine who used Rodrigo’s youth and proximity to fame for his personal ends. The phrase “fame-fucker” seems within the lyrics as a particular insult, which has only a few precedents at this business scale.
The anger right here isn’t the generalised heartbreak of the debut. She understood what was taking place and he did it anyway. That place offers the vocal a special high quality on the ultimate part. The pressure within the voice isn’t despair. It’s recognition.
What the manufacturing does, structurally, is construct in three distinct gear modifications. It begins with sparse piano and a sluggish, funereal tempo.
After the primary refrain, Nigro provides a double-time pulse that accelerates the momentum with out lifting the emotional register. The tempo doubles however the temper stays darkish.
By the ultimate part, full distorted guitars arrive and the track turns into one thing near a rock outro. Every shift corresponds to a special lyrical place: grief, then anger, then recognition.
The vampire idea might have been a gimmick. As an alternative Rodrigo and Nigro use the prolonged type as a result of the track genuinely wants room to maneuver by means of these levels. A 3-minute model must select one.
Full “vampire” lyrics which means and breakdown
Lacy
“I despise my rotten thoughts and the way a lot it worships you.” That closing line is the sharpest lyric on the album, and it lands as a result of the track has spent three minutes making the narrator absolutely seen to herself. “lacy” was initially written as a poem.
It describes an obsession with one other girl, a determine named Lacy, whose magnificence and obvious effortlessness generate equal quantities of admiration and corrosive self-loathing within the narrator.
The track refuses to supply narrative context for the connection, which is the correct determination. The sensation is the topic, not the circumstances.
The association is generally voice and sparse instrumentation. A vocal processing impact creates a slight ethereal distance between the narrator and what she is describing, as if she is observing the obsession from barely outdoors herself.
That distance issues as a result of it means the narrator isn’t misplaced within the feeling, she will be able to see precisely what is occurring to her. Which makes the closing line extra devastating somewhat than much less.
The self-awareness doesn’t launch her from it. The track’s ultimate transfer is to notice that clearly and cease there.
Rodrigo holds the stress between eager to be somebody and wanting that particular person in a means that refuses to resolve cleanly. The paradox in regards to the nature of the sensation isn’t evasion. It’s accuracy.
ballad of a homeschooled woman
The title is essentially the most audacious on the document. The monitor itself delivers. Rodrigo catalogues particular moments of social failure with real comedian timing, framing each as a specific small catastrophe: smashing glasses, speaking to the flawed particular person, lacking the social register of a room utterly.
The fuzz on the guitars is heavier right here than anyplace else on the album, and the vocal is pushed near the distortion restrict. The rhythm part locks in beneath and stays there, which retains the chaos from changing into uncontrolled.
The self-deprecation doesn’t ask for sympathy. It identifies social nervousness as one thing that persists no matter exterior success, and the specificity of the moments she picks, not summary unease however concrete cringeworthy occasions, is what retains the track from changing into a lament.
making the mattress
Being handled like a vacationer attraction. Haunted by desires of a automotive with out brakes that can’t swerve off the street. “making the mattress” is about reaching what you wished and discovering the achievement doesn’t really feel the way in which you anticipated, and people photos don’t attain for universality.
They’re particular to an individual who obtained someplace too quick to develop the emotional tools for it.
The vocal carries a rasp that features otherwise from the rasp elsewhere on the document.
Right here it seems like weariness somewhat than a manufacturing alternative, which is the excellence the track must work. Piano anchors a minimal association.
That is Rodrigo writing from inside her precise state of affairs somewhat than from the angle of relationships and social conditions, and with out it the album might be accused of performing adolescence somewhat than inhabiting it.
Logical
The construction pairs genuinely irrational conduct with rationalizations that nearly maintain collectively, which is the correct technique to describe how individuals navigate relationships they know are damaging however can not go away.
The refrain vocal is essentially the most technically demanding on the album, and Rodrigo holds the pitch and emotional register by means of it with out letting both slip.
The subtext about energy dynamics runs all through. Recognising an unhealthy sample doesn’t make leaving simple, and the track sits with that somewhat than resolving it. The place “logical” loses floor is within the manufacturing, which delivers the lyric accurately with out including something alongside it.
On “all-american bitch,” the association makes a counter-case: the acoustic verse performs the compliance the lyric is offended about, so the shift to distorted refrain enacts the failure of that efficiency.
On “vampire,” every manufacturing gear change corresponds to a definite emotional place within the writing. “logical” doesn’t work that means.
The piano and percussion are organized to assist what the lyric says, nothing extra. For a track in regards to the hole between what you realize and what you do, that absence of friction is the monitor’s fundamental downside.
get him again!
“I’m my father’s daughter, I stated perhaps I can repair him.” That line, a reference to Rodrigo’s therapist father, is humorous and particular and earns its precision by not explaining itself. The joke is within the juxtaposition. She doesn’t break it open. That sort of restraint is a special confidence from the emotional directness elsewhere on the document. She trusts the listener to shut the hole somewhat than closing it for them.
The manufacturing is heavier right here than anyplace on the album’s second half: distorted bassline, a woozy results layer, a refrain constructed to be shouted in giant rooms.
The paradox within the title carries the entire track. Getting revenge and getting him again romantically are each current all through, neither resolves, and Rodrigo retains each readings stay proper to the top. The track would collapse if it dedicated to both.
What “get him again!” actually means
teenage dream
The album closes the place it opened: with Rodrigo inspecting how she is perceived somewhat than merely how she feels.
“teenage dream” interrogates what it means to have been celebrated primarily as a prodigy, to be “nice for my age” somewhat than merely nice, and whether or not the elements of herself that linked with individuals had been already given away earlier than she was sufficiently old to know their worth.
That could be a particular concern, not a generalised one, and the track earns it by naming it plainly somewhat than dressing it up.
The manufacturing is stripped again in a means that mirrors “making the mattress” however lands otherwise. The place that monitor seems like value, “teenage dream” seems like reckoning.
The piano sits alone below many of the verse, and Rodrigo doesn’t push the vocal towards the theatrical escalations she makes use of elsewhere. By the ultimate traces she isn’t constructing to a refrain. She is simply asking the query and leaving it there.
The again half of the document loses one thing, and the explanations are price inspecting somewhat than simply noting. “love is embarrassing” describes the precise humiliation of realising you may have wasted consideration on somebody who was not price it.
The lyrical content material is strong. However the manufacturing is softer and extra blurred than the monitor wants, guitars muddied below reverb in a means that reads as a stylistic alternative with no cause.
By this level the album has established that Nigro and Rodrigo know what they’re doing with dynamics. A quieter monitor ought to really feel like an intentional gear change. “love is embarrassing” seems like deflation.
“the grudge” is the album’s most polished ballad and its most standard. The lyric “damage individuals damage individuals, and we each drew blood, however man these cuts had been by no means equal” is without doubt one of the finest traces on the document: it acknowledges shared culpability and rejects false equivalence in the identical sentence. The remainder of the track doesn’t work as arduous.
The piano and string association is competent and generic, which is a particular failure mode when the stronger tracks have demonstrated that association can carry as a lot which means because the writing.
The bridge is the exception: Rodrigo lets the voice carry the emotional launch alone, with out instrumental assist, and it really works. Extra of that decision-making would have made the monitor.
“fairly isn’t fairly” recovers some floor. The lyrical content material addresses magnificence customary exhaustion at a barely extra generic register than the remainder of the album, however the manufacturing does particular work to compensate.
The guitar shimmer sits immediately on prime of lyrics about painful self-scrutiny, making a floor brightness that doesn’t soften the discomfort. It makes it extra seen, the identical structural rigidity as “all-american bitch” achieved by reverse means.
The place that monitor makes use of prettiness to arrange the explosion, “fairly isn’t fairly” makes use of it to carry the stress in place with out releasing it. The drum momentum beneath retains the track from settling into grievance.
The manufacturing isn’t illustrating the lyric. It’s arguing towards it, and that friction is what earns the monitor its place.
The sequencing is the structural downside. Three softer, much less propulsive tracks in a row after “get him again!” ask for endurance that the primary half has not ready you to increase. Rodrigo is a robust sufficient author that the songs maintain individually. As a sequence, they cease shifting.
Vocal Efficiency
The hole between Rodrigo on SOUR and Rodrigo on GUTS is best to listen to in how she makes use of management as a weapon.
On the debut, the dynamic shifts between whisper and shout had been emotionally direct. Right here she has developed a 3rd mode: a half-committed, deadpan supply used on “unhealthy thought proper?” and sections of “get him again!” that means somebody performing a sense somewhat than having it. That ironic distance is new. It permits the humour to land with out undermining the emotional content material of the document’s extra direct tracks.
On “vampire,” the rasp arrives late, solely within the ultimate part, after the manufacturing has constructed by means of two gear modifications to earn it. It reads because the bodily residue of the track’s escalation, one thing the efficiency has accrued somewhat than began with.
On “the grudge,” the rasp is current a lot earlier and sits extra evenly throughout the monitor, which works towards it. It reads as a manufacturing texture, a alternative about how the vocal ought to sound, somewhat than one thing the track has value her. “making the mattress” will get this proper once more.
The weariness within the voice on that monitor sounds just like the precise factor, not a call about methods to ship the road. The excellence is between a sound that the track produces and a sound that’s utilized to it.
What GUTS Settles
GUTS isn’t a reinvention. The territory is recognisable from SOUR: relationships, self-image, the expertise of being a particular age below a particular sort of scrutiny.
What has modified is the precision and the vary. Rodrigo at 20 is a extra full author than Rodrigo at 18.
The album demonstrates that SOUR was not a one-off cultural alignment. There’s a author right here who is aware of what she is doing and, extra importantly, is aware of when the work isn’t doing sufficient.
The closing monitor asks whether or not issues get higher, then solutions: “what if I don’t?” That query is left genuinely open. It’s the proper ending for an album that has spent its runtime dealing in specificity a couple of state of affairs that’s not but completed.
You may additionally like:
