Join Chalkbeat Tennessee’s free publication to maintain up with statewide schooling coverage and Memphis-Shelby County Colleges.
Tennessee Legal professional Normal Jonathan Skrmetti won’t intervene in an ongoing lawsuit over the state’s spiritual constitution faculty ban, leaving the Knox County Board of Schooling to defend a state coverage in opposition to claims of non secular discrimination.
The Wilberforce Academy of Knoxville, represented by an lawyer at present working for Skrmetti’s workplace in a unique case, sued the college district late final yr in federal courtroom.
The case might deliver a contemporary problem to the spiritual constitution concern that deadlocked the U.S. Supreme Court docket in 2025.
Although Wilberforce shouldn’t be suing the state of Tennessee, it’s difficult the constitutionality of Tennessee’s longstanding constitution faculty legislation. Beneath federal laws, state attorneys common have to be notified and given the choice to intervene in lawsuits with constitutional challenges.
Skrmetti declined to intervene earlier this month, in line with courtroom filings. His workplace didn’t touch upon the submitting however pointed to a November authorized opinion Skrmetti wrote that questioned the constitutionality of Tennessee’s personal legislation.
Skrmetti argued there was “no compelling curiosity” in excluding spiritual constitution faculties from taking part in a “public profit.”
In its lawsuit, Wilberforce focuses partly on Tennessee’s new voucher program, basically arguing that the general public schooling funds now flowing to personal spiritual faculties help the case that spiritual charters needs to be included in public funding.
“This enshrined hostility to spiritual constitution faculties stands in marked distinction to Tennessee’s latest help of non secular faculties by means of its Schooling Freedom Scholarship Program,” a Wilberforce lawyer argued in courtroom paperwork final yr.
Gov. Invoice Lee, who pushed for the voucher program to permit personal spiritual faculties to obtain public {dollars}, demurred on Thursday when requested if he believes state legislation needs to be modified to permit spiritual charters.
“The Legal professional Normal has the position in figuring out what’s constitutional, what needs to be legislation within the state,” Lee stated. “I’d defer to him on that.”
Nonprofit sued days after registering with the state
Days after Skrmetti’s November authorized opinion was revealed, Wilberforce sued the Knox County Board of Schooling in federal courtroom, alleging specific spiritual discrimination over native and state guidelines banning spiritual constitution faculties.
On Nov. 25, simply 4 days after it registered as a nonprofit with the state, Wilberforce submitted a letter of intent to the Knox County Board of Schooling to point curiosity in opening an “explicitly Christian faculty” in 2027.
The board wouldn’t settle for the letter, in line with courtroom paperwork, as a result of Wilberforce wouldn’t affirm the state requirement that or not it’s a nonsectarian and non-religious faculty.
Knox County attorneys say Wilberforce by no means accomplished a constitution utility, and subsequently they haven’t been denied something.
Final week, a federal decide denied Wilberforce’s request for a ruling that will instantly block the Knox County board from imposing the state ban on spiritual charters. A trial on the problem is scheduled for January 2027.
Regardless of Skrmetti’s hands-off method to the lawsuit, an lawyer working with the lawyer common’s workplace is at present representing Wilberforce in its lawsuit in opposition to the Tennessee faculty district.
In 2023, Lee appointed Cameron Norris, a Virginia-based lawyer with the conservative legislation agency Consovoy McCarthy, to assist defend Tennessee in a lawsuit over the state legislation banning gender transition remedies for minors.
Skrmetti’s workplace has continued to rent Norris as outdoors counsel in two circumstances since, in line with data reviewed by Chalkbeat Tennessee. Norris at present earns $400 per hour, paid by public funds, to assist Tennessee defend its prison abortion ban in opposition to ongoing authorized challenges.
A bunch of Knox County mother and father have joined the Knox County board to oppose Wilberforce’s lawsuit.
“I imagine that public schooling is a part of the widespread good and that sustaining the integrity of public schooling ensures that public faculties stay acceptable for and welcoming to college students of all faiths and backgrounds,” stated Amanda Collins, a retired faculty psychologist whose three kids both attend or attended Knox County public faculties. “These basic tenets are at odds with a spiritual faculty.”
Melissa Brown is the bureau chief for Chalkbeat Tennessee. Contact Melissa at mbrown@chalkbeat.org.
