Join Chalkbeat Tennessee’s free e-newsletter to maintain up with statewide training coverage and Memphis-Shelby County Faculties.
Tennessee Home Republican leaders will push ahead a plan in 2026 to put in a Memphis-Shelby County faculties oversight panel that might seize vital decision-making authority from the regionally elected faculty board.
Home Speaker Cameron Sexton and training committee Chairman Mark White confirmed this month they’re dedicated to working with the Senate to go a type of takeover laws within the 2026 legislative session.
Republicans within the two chambers didn’t discover a compromise after passing differing variations of the invoice earlier this 12 months amid ongoing frustrations with faculty board governance and tutorial efficiency points. If lawmakers can agree this 12 months, change might come shortly to Memphis-Shelby County faculties, which is already primed for main upheaval in 2026.
White’s plan would basically set up a governing oversight board with the authority to veto half or all the native faculty board’s price range, the most important single determination the varsity board is liable for.
White argued the oversight board should have the “tooth” to make vital district choices, in comparison with the 2025 Senate model of the plan that might function as an advisory board.
The oversight board below White’s plan would even have approval authority for any contracts or bills bigger than $50,000 and basically management remaining constitution choices within the district. White’s proposal would institute the board for 3 years, with the potential for one more three-year extension.
“Placing a board in place that has no authority to do something is a waste of time,” Sexton mentioned. “It does nothing. In case you’re going to place it in, then you definitely’ve acquired to belief them to make the selections.”
Sen. Brent Taylor, a Memphis Republican carrying the Senate model of the invoice, didn’t reply to a request for remark.
The Senate and Home handed differing variations of the laws in 2025, with the two chambers at odds over particulars of oversight board authority.
If Senate and Home leaders can come to a compromise on the laws when the Basic Meeting reconvenes in mid-January, it might shortly be handed into legislation. As a result of the payments are nonetheless reside, the chambers might hash out any adjustments in convention with out reverting again to a prolonged legislative committee course of.
Potential oversight adjustments could be one among a number of vital adjustments on the horizon for Memphis faculties.
The early 2025 firing of former Superintendent Marie Feagins ignited long-simmering dissatisfaction with the varsity board and triggered each native and state backlash. Now, all 9 seats on the board are up for election in 2026, which means Memphis voters could go to the first poll field this spring to vote for a board whose governing energy might quickly be significantly diminished below the legislative plan.
The board should additionally decide on the interim superintendent’s contract someday in 2026.
White mentioned he’ll transfer “full velocity forward” to enact “drastic” adjustments.
“I don’t consider an elected faculty board can repair many years of paperwork. I’m not placing blame on any previous or current faculty board,” White mentioned.
Legislative Democrats and Memphis-Shelby County faculty leaders have sharply criticized the takeover effort as political overreach, pointing to earlier state takeover failures within the Achievement College District and incremental progress the district has made lately.
“State intervention in Memphis faculties has traditionally failed to enhance outcomes,” Memphis-Shelby County faculties interim Superintendent Roderick Richmond mentioned throughout a fall neighborhood assembly.
Launched a decade in the past, the Achievement College District took management of low-performing faculties and infrequently turned them over to the constitution operators. However the state intervention mannequin led to no significant long-term enhancements for college students, analysis confirmed, and infrequently sparked neighborhood backlash for takeovers in low-income neighborhoods.
Memphis faculties have had some progress lately. This 12 months, MSCS college students outpaced the state common for tutorial progress in studying and math. Extra Memphis faculties additionally earned prime marks in Tennessee’s report card system for the 2024-2025 faculty 12 months.
But the district continues to lag considerably in tutorial achievement, with lower than 25% of MSCS college students assembly grade stage benchmarks in studying and math on state exams.
Sexton recommended any enchancment is simply too little, too late after many years of underperformance within the state’s largest faculty district.
Republicans are additionally eyeing an ongoing state monetary audit of the district, although each Sexton and White mentioned the takeover laws would transfer forward no matter these findings.
White has denied that the laws quantities to a state takeover, on condition that members of the governing board have to be residents of Shelby County. White says he, together with different Memphis natives, consider “we now have to have native intervention.”
However below White’s 2025 invoice, the appointing energy for the oversight board would sit in state authorities and, by extension, give the Republican Occasion governing authority of native faculties in a majority Democratic county.
Underneath the Home invoice, the Tennessee governor would appoint 5 members, and the Home and Senate audio system would obtain two appointments every.
Critics of the laws have additionally warned the measure might have ripple results past Memphis and encroach on native management in different areas of the state, although the laws presently solely applies to Shelby County. White’s 2025 laws might set off an oversight board in an area district if:
- 50% or extra of enrolled college students didn’t meet state testing grade stage expectations.
- 30% or extra of faculties in a district obtain a D or F state letter grade.
- 25% or extra of scholars enrolled had been chronically absent in the latest faculty 12 months.
- A number of faculties have been recognized as a precedence school by the state training division.
- And the native legislative physique of the county approves a decision of no confidence within the native faculty board.
Melissa Brown is the bureau chief for Chalkbeat Tennessee. Contact Melissa at mbrown@chalkbeat.org.
