OPINION — “Practically 1,000 ft beneath the Nevada desert, [U.S.] scientists and engineers are conducting groundbreaking nuclear weapons analysis. Subcritical experiments, or ‘subcrits’ for brief, play a vital position in guaranteeing nationwide safety. Subcritical experiments are a key a part of the [National Nuclear Security Administration (NNSA)] science-based Stockpile Stewardship Program, which is the way in which America ensures that our nuclear weapons are secure, safe, and dependable — with out conducting full-scale nuclear weapons exams.”
That was a quote from Don Haynes, Los Alamos Nationwide Laboratory (LANL) senior director on the Nevada Nationwide Safety Websites, from an article revealed in LANL’s Nationwide Safety Science journal simply 13 days in the past on October 29, 2025.
The article goes on to clarify, “Subcritical experiments enable researchers to judge the habits of nuclear supplies (normally plutonium) together with excessive explosives. This configuration mimics the fission stage of a contemporary nuclear weapon. Nevertheless, subcrits stay beneath the edge of reaching criticality. No important mass is shaped, and no self-sustaining nuclear chain response happens — there is no such thing as a nuclear explosion.”
I’m going to cite extra from the LANL article as a result of it exhibits what subcritical testing the U.S. has been doing for years. For instance, I wrote a Cipher Temporary column in July 2021 that described subcrits this fashion: “Put merely, inside a metal container, a chemical high-explosive is detonated round a coin-like, small pattern of plutonium [less than eight ounces] to simulate points of a nuclear explosion. No precise chain response or nuclear explosion happens. However this contained detonation, with the help of computer systems, has helped scientists decide how plutonium behaves below the intense pressures that do happen throughout detonation of a nuclear weapon.”
I additional defined 4 years in the past, “The principle function, to date, of subcritical experiments has been to determine and reduce uncertainties within the efficiency of at present deployed U.S. nuclear weapons, at a time when precise testing is just not being carried out.”
I write this to cope with President Trump’s fairly confused – and at occasions inaccurate — collection of current statements about restarting U.S. nuclear testing. The President’s phrases have brought about different responses from his personal officers – a few of whom apparently didn’t need to seem correcting him. And the President’s phrases have gone as far as to encourage Russian President Vladimir Putin to convene a publicized Kremlin assembly final Wednesday the place senior Russian nationwide safety officers mentioned the potential for Russia exploring the restart of their very own full-scale underground nuclear testing.
To make it clear, the U.S. and Russia, by settlement, performed their final underground nuclear exams in 1992. China did their final one in 1996. All three had been signatories to the 1996 Complete Nuclear Check Ban Treaty (CTBT), which prohibited “any nuclear weapon check explosion or another nuclear explosion.” Nevertheless, below the treaty, because the U.S. State Division explains on its web site, the CTBT “doesn’t prohibit subcritical experiments to assist make sure the continued security and reliability of nuclear weapons.”
The Cipher Temporary brings expert-level context to nationwide and international safety tales. It’s by no means been extra vital to know what’s occurring on the earth. Improve your entry to unique content material by turning into a subscriber.
Russia has performed at the least 25 subcritical experiments at its Novaya Zemlya check website, in line with previous statements by U.S. Division of Power (DOE) and Russian authorities. As of Might 2024, the U.S. had performed some 34 subcrits on the Nevada check website, in line with DOE.
In 2022, a spokesperson for DOE’s Nationwide Nuclear Safety Administration (NNSA), which manages the nuclear program, instructed Kyodo Information that in June and September 2021, the U.S. performed two subcritical exams, the primary below the Biden administration. Three rounds of subcritical nuclear exams had been performed below the primary Trump administration, and 4 rounds below Obama, in line with different sources.
Presently, LANL has subcritical experiments scheduled into the 12 months 2032, in line with the current Nationwide Safety Science journal article.
In the meantime, the U.S. is growing a number of new warheads together with the W93, which is meant for deployment on U.S. sub-launched ballistic missiles by 2040, in line with NNSA. The NNSA web site stated of the W93, “Key nuclear elements will probably be primarily based on at present deployed and/or beforehand examined nuclear designs…The W93 won’t require further nuclear testing.”
In opposition to that background, let’s overview what President Trump has been saying, together with a number of the responses.
The testing difficulty started with Trump in Korea on the night of October 29. He had a gathering scheduled for 11 a.m. the following morning with Chinese language Chief Xi Jinping. At 9 p.m., Trump despatched off a message on his Reality Social public web site that stated: “America has extra Nuclear Weapons than another nation. This was completed, together with an entire replace and renovation of present weapons, throughout my First Time period in workplace. Due to the great harmful energy, I HATED to do it, however had no selection! Russia is second, and China is a distant third, however will probably be even inside 5 years. Due to different nations’ testing packages, I’ve instructed the Division of Struggle to start out testing our Nuclear Weapons on an equal foundation. That course of will start instantly.”
What triggered Trump’s message has not but been defined. Three days earlier, Putin, wearing a army uniform, had publicly introduced with some fanfare that Russia had efficiently examined a nuclear-powered missile over the Arctic Ocean after years of growth.
It could have been simply competitiveness, however Trump was not clear what he was speaking about when he wrote “testing our nuclear weapons.” Was he speaking about nuclear supply programs, as Putin had simply been? Or was he speaking about testing nuclear warheads or bombs?
If it had been the latter, Russia truly has extra nuclear weapons than the U.S., primarily as a result of the U.S. has retired most of its tactical nuclear weapons. But when Trump meant strategic nuclear supply programs, he was appropriate.
Then there was the anomaly of what sort of testing Trump was speaking about? He mentions instructing the Pentagon to “begin testing,” which implied nuclear supply programs, akin to missiles, which the army controls. DOE’s NNSA exams the nuclear portion of warheads and bombs.
The following day, October 30, hours after the Xi assembly, Trump was flying again to the U.S. from Korea aboard Air Power One, and held an impromptu press convention. After 10 minutes of questions on assembly Xi, Trump was requested why he wrote the Reality Social piece about nuclear testing, Trump initially replied, “Nicely, that had nothing to do with them,” which means the Chinese language.
Trump went on, “It needed to do with others.” He paused after which continued, “They appear to all be nuclear testing. Now we have extra nuclear weapons than anyone. We do not do testing. You understand, we have halted it years, a few years in the past, however with others doing testing, I feel it is applicable that we do.”
Since Trump talked about the U.S. had halted the testing “years in the past,” he created the impression at that second he should have been pondering of explosive underground nuclear testing. When requested a follow-up query on the place or when such testing would happen, Trump waved it off saying, “Will probably be introduced. You understand, we’ve check websites. It will be introduced.”
Having given the concept that he had ordered the resumption of explosive underground nuclear exams, it was no shock that the following day, Friday, October 31, when Trump sat down at Mar-a-Lago with Norah O’Donnell for the 60 Minutes CBS Information tv program to be aired two days later.
Right here I’m utilizing the CBS transcript of the complete one-hour, thirteen-minute Trump/O’Donnell interview and never the shorter, edited model proven on Sunday evening, October 31.
Are you Subscribed to The Cipher Temporary’s Digital Channel on YouTube? There isn’t any higher place to get clear views from deeply skilled nationwide safety consultants.
Nicely into the interview, after masking Trump’s Asia journey and assembly with China’s Xi, O’Donnell referred to his October 29, Reality Social message the place he talked about new nuclear testing and requested Trump, “What did you imply?”
Trump initially gave this wide-ranging response: “Nicely, we’ve extra nuclear weapons than another nation. Russia’s second. China’s a really distant third, however they will be even in 5 years. You understand, they’re making them quickly, and I feel we should always do one thing about denuclearization, which goes to be some– and I did truly talk about that with each President Putin and President Xi. Denuclearization’s a really large factor. Now we have sufficient nuclear weapons to explode the world 150 occasions. Russia has lots of nuclear weapons, and China could have lots. They’ve some. They’ve fairly a bit, however…”
At that time, O’Donnell interrupted and requested particularly, “So why do we have to check our nuclear weapons?”
This time Trump answered, “Nicely, as a result of you need to see how they work. You understand, you do have to– and the explanation I am saying– testing is as a result of Russia introduced that they had been going be doing a check. In case you discover, North Korea’s testing consistently. Different nations are testing. We’re the one nation that does not check, and I don’t need to be the one nation that does not check.”
As I’ve identified above, aside from North Korea’s six underground nuclear exams starting in 2006 and ending in September 2017, there have been none confirmed, aside from Russia’s acknowledged subcritical nuclear exams. So it once more is unclear what Trump was mentioning.
Trump truly went on saying, “Now we have great nuclear energy that was given to us largely as a result of once I was President (and I hated to do it, however you need to do it)– I rebuilt the army throughout my first time period. My first time period was an incredible success. We had the best financial system within the historical past of our nation.”
Trump then tried to show the dialog to the financial system, however O’Donnell introduced him again to the topic by asking, “Are you saying that after greater than 30 years, america goes to start out detonating nuclear weapons for testing?”
This time Trump insisted, “I am saying that we’ll check nuclear weapons like different nations do, sure,” and went on saying “Russia’s testing nuclear weapons…And China’s testing them too. You simply do not find out about it.”
Trump claimed the U.S. is an open society, however “they [Russia, China] do not go and let you know about it. And, you already know, as highly effective as they’re, this can be a large world. You do not essentially know the place they’re testing. They check means underground the place individuals do not know precisely what’s occurring with the check. You are feeling a bit little bit of a vibration. They check and we do not check. Now we have to check.”
That very same day of the Trump/O’Donnell interview, October 30, Vice Admiral Richard Correll, Trump’s nominee to be head of Strategic Command, was having his affirmation listening to earlier than the Senate Armed Providers Committee. Requested if he knew whether or not Russia, China or another nation had been doing explosive testing of nuclear warheads, Correll answered, “No.”
Requested whether or not Trump might have been speaking about nuclear supply programs, Correll stated, “I haven’t got perception into the President’s intent. I agree that may very well be an interpretation.”
On November 2, Power Secretary Chris Wright appeared on Fox Information and was requested concerning the new nuclear exams talked about by the President. Wright replied, “I feel the exams we’re speaking about proper now are system exams. These should not nuclear explosions. These are what we name non-critical explosions.”
Requested whether or not the exams contain the prevailing stockpile weapons or new programs, Wright stated, “The testing that we’ll be doing is on new programs, and once more these will probably be non-nuclear explosions.”
Wright defined that because of the nation’s nationwide laboratories “the U.S. truly has an incredible benefit with our science and our computation energy. We are able to simulate extremely precisely precisely what’s going to occur in a nuclear explosion. And we will do this as a result of within the 60s, 70s, and 80s, we did nuclear check explosions. We had them detailed and instrumented and we measured precisely what occurred. Now we simulate what had been the circumstances that delivered that and as we modify bomb designs, what’s going to they ship. Now we have an affordable benefit at the moment in nuclear weapons design over all of our adversaries.”
On November 3, CIA Director John Ratcliffe got here to Trump’s protection on the Russia, China testing difficulty, writing a Tweet on X saying the President “is correct.” To again it up, Ratcliffe cited a Might 2019 quote from then-Protection Intelligence Company Director Lt. Gen. Robert Ashley Jr. saying Russia “most likely” was conducting low-yield exams though Ashley didn’t declare to have particular proof. He acknowledged that Russia had the “functionality” to conduct very low-yield nuclear exams.
Ratcliffe additionally cited a 2020 Wall Avenue Journal article that stated the U.S. believed China might have secretly performed a low-yield nuclear check primarily based on circumstantial proof, akin to elevated excavation, exercise in containment chambers, and a scarcity of transparency on the website.
That very same day, Sen. Tom Cotton, chairman of the Senate Intelligence Committee, put out his personal Tweet on X saying, “After consultations with Director Ratcliffe and his staff, they’ve confirmed to me that the CIA assesses that each Russia and China have performed super-critical nuclear weapons exams in extra of the U.S. zero-yield customary. These exams should not historic and are a part of their nuclear modernization packages.”
Regardless of all this Trumpian forwards and backwards, I strongly doubt the U.S. will return to explosive nuclear testing, however fairly stay with subcritical experiments as at present deliberate.
The Cipher Temporary is dedicated to publishing a variety of views on nationwide safety points submitted by deeply skilled nationwide safety professionals.
Opinions expressed are these of the creator and don’t symbolize the views or opinions of The Cipher Temporary.
Have a perspective to share primarily based in your expertise within the nationwide safety discipline? Ship it to Editor@thecipherbrief.com for publication consideration.
Learn extra expert-driven nationwide safety insights, perspective and evaluation in The Cipher Temporary as a result of Nationwide Safety is everybody’s enterprise.
