Olivia Dean/Youtube/Screenshot by NPR
If there is a essential message to be distilled from the collected pop songs made by younger ladies in the previous few years, it is that boys can kick rocks.
The boys these younger artists discover themselves entangled with, they sing, are idiots and vampires. They’re dudes who take you on a date and do not truly ask you a single query, or they deal with you want “s*** on [their] footwear.” They’re simply manchildren, within the parlance of Sabrina Carpenter’s newest hit, who cannot maintain themselves, flailing via life. Typically these insults are sung much less in anger than with what seems like humorous, even self-deprecating exasperation, guffawing on the sorry state of what is out there to them as ladies of their 20s attempting to this point in an period when main information shops constantly print thinkpieces asking if “males are okay.” “Perhaps I can repair him?” Olivia Rodrigo requested, with fun, on 2023’s “get him again!” after itemizing a litany of faults (“an ego, a mood and a wandering eye”) an irredeemable however irresistible ex-boyfriend possessed. Apparently that is all some women can hope for.
Olivia Dean hopes for extra. At first look, the 26-year-old English singer, whose 2023 debut album Messy was shortlisted for the U.Ok.’s Mercury Prize, shares little in widespread with pop friends who’ve discovered success in saltily degrading potential suitors. The artist hails initially from the BRIT college, the distinguished London music college that additionally produced Adele and RAYE, and Dean’s work performs with the identical acquainted, brassy English soul influences these artists pull from. Her songs about love and even romantic ambivalence have an ethereal, seductive simplicity, her heat voice constructed for first dances at weddings and blockbuster rom-com montages that includes the lead actors falling in love over candlelit dinners and respectable small plates. And even when she’s ragging on somebody who will get on her nerves — admittedly “choosing a struggle” — Dean would not sound like she’s combating one bit. She sounds cool and picked up, resigned to nonetheless the scenario would possibly play out.
Dean’s “Man I Want,” which was her first tune to chart on Billboard‘s Sizzling 100 and has been climbing steadily, sits in the identical universe as so a lot of her friends’ songs about courting males of various levels of unavailability. However there’s zero snark right here — no frustration, no rage. A self-described tune about “realizing the way you need to be liked and never being afraid to ask for it,” “Man I Want” is playful and lightweight, its bouncy, jazzy pop piano setting the tempo as Dean sings of attempting to reign in a lover who’s holding her at a distance. “Simply come be the person I want,” Dean sings. “Inform me you bought one thing to provide, I would like it.”
YouTube
On the floor, “Man I Want” matches into that rising catalog of “get it collectively, boys!”-themed pop hits helmed by fed-up younger ladies. However it would not talk the identical sass or depth as of her friends’ songs in that area, and possibly due to that, it lacks the identical feeling of actual, human funding. There’s one thing about “Man I Want” that jogs my memory of a cardboard cut-out, just like the tune is merely an commercial for its earnest message quite than an embodiment of it. Like I might flick my finger at its edge and it would topple over within the foyer of a movie show. That is likely to be as a result of it form of seems like a stage musical quantity, the groundwork of what might be an actual life dialog dramatized right into a sprightly, transparently retro efficiency. That the tune’s music video takes place on a soundstage (as her different movies have) with the innards of some form of manufacturing uncovered, Dean dancing in entrance of hand-painted backdrops and transferring units pushed out and in of body by a multiplying group of good-looking males, solely emphasizes the music’s self-aware facade.
However “Man I Want” additionally seems like cardboard as a result of Dean’s calls for are skinny. She simply needs him to speak to her — “no matter the kind of speak it’s,” actually — and at one level non-committedly drops that she’s already given him “the time and the place, so do not be shy.” Within the tune’s mushiest greeting card line, she permits that “I kinda prefer it once you name me great.” Regardless of being billed as a tune that is not afraid of expression, “Man I Want” hedges, takes the straightforward manner out, settles for sentimentality. Of the singles launched from Dean’s new sophomore album The Artwork of Loving, I am extra keen on “Good to Every Different,” which, regardless of its equally peppy instrumentation, performs prefer it was written by an individual truly immersed within the realities of a relationship, this one informal however not with out feelings or stakes concerned. “We might be good to one another, unsuitable for one another, proper for one another,” she sings, sitting within the relationship’s shifting ambiguity. It is a easy, swaying refrain, and when Dean sings it, with the echoes of backup singers behind her, the tune sounds prefer it might have been penned for a ’60s woman group. It additionally would not sound like taking the straightforward manner out.
